Pitch was born in 1975 in Jersey City, New Jersey. He grew up playing football and baseball. He graduated from Marist High School in 1993. In 1995, he went into the Navy as an Aviation Electricians Mate (AT).
In 2002, he went through and graduated BUD/s training and became a Navy Seal. Pitch did two tours to Iraq and one to the Philippines with Seal Team 5. He joined the Navy reserves in 2009 and retired from the Navy in 2016. He currently works as a private contractor. Pitch is married, has three daughters and lives in Las Vegas, Nevada.